The
following comments on this specimen are courtesy of Fred Sundberg and
James Cook:
The box shape pygidium with numerous spines is common in the Zacanthoides
from the Glossopleura and Ehmaniella Biozone (these may need to be made
a different genus). Dr. Sundberg is currently working on Z. sampsoni Resser,
1938, from the Lakeview Limestone of Idaho, Glossopleura Biozone. The
species here is similar, but the frontal area does not have the strongly
divergent anterior branches of the facial sutures typical of Z. sampsoni
or Z. divergens Rasetti (Ehmaniella Biozone). This specimen is also similar
to Zacanthoides sexdentatus Rasetti, 1951 (Albertella Biozone), but lacks
the well developed pleural and interpleural furrows on the pygidium and
has a more rectancular shape pygidium.
When comparing with Resser, 1939 on the Spence Shale and its fauna, this
specimen looks like Z. serratus Resser, 1939. Also, it has similarities
to Zacanthoides spinosus (Walcott, 1884) figured in Palmer, 1954. Palmer
discusses the similarity of Z. spinosus to Z. typicalis, but mentions
an expanding frontal lobe and a rectangular pygidium. The specimen here
does not have a pygidium that is as rectangular. It
is also similar to the pygidium of Zacanthoides variacantha, that is
reported in the Nevada Test Site, Albertella Zone, Zacanthoidid Zonal.
The pygidium of Z.variacantha has one outer long pair of marginal spines,
and four pairs of very short marginal spines. The pygidium the Chisholm
trilobite has the four pairs of inner spines, but the outer spine pair
does not appear to be big/long.
So, is
this specimen from the Chisholm a new species? Perhaps, but the cranidium
is too crushed to distinguish some important features. Dr. Sundberg
recommends to perhaps refer the species as Zacanthoides cf. spinosus
(Walcott, 1884) until further specimens are recovered. It is also possible
it could be Zacanthoides cf. serratus Resser, 1939, although the original
photos of this species are poor. With the collection of more specimens
(including cranidia and pygidia), the assignment of this species from
the Chisholm may be narrowed down. |